Government Failing On Animal Welfare, Says Protection Agency

The government should not seek recommendations from the traders of exotic animals, says APA. Credit: Pixabay

The Animal Protection Agency calls for an urgent shake-up of how the UK government consults on animal welfare and conservation. Seeking evidence and recommendations on wild animal welfare primarily from exotic pet traders is akin to putting the fox in charge of the chicken, the agency said.

The Animal Protection Agency (APA) is calling on governments to prioritise information firstly from independent scientists, secondly from animal welfare, conservation and environmental organisations, and lastly from those whose actions may cause animal suffering, disrupt ecosystems or threaten public health.

“Bizarrely, governments in Britain and elsewhere formally prioritise advice from certain sectors that generate multiple harms, rather than independent experts or groups that seek to remedy problems,” said Dr Clifford Warwick.

Using the trading and keeping of wild animals as an example, a new scientific study published in the Journal of Veterinary Behavior sets out how DEFRA, the Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs, routinely assigns greater importance to evidence from vested interests than it does from independent scientists or animal welfare organisations. APA is now calling for the urgent adoption of a new ‘Model Government Consultation and Advisory Protocol’.

Dr Clifford Warwick, the lead author of the article, said, “Exotic pet trading and keeping is responsible for diverse and serious concerns, thus the sector provided a good example to test governmental approaches to the advice it receives from stakeholders that cause problems versus those that aim to ameliorate them. I think the public would be rightly dismayed to learn that the English Government actually places advice from the harm-doers above do-gooders. Unsurprisingly, animal welfare, public health and safety, species loss, ecological damage, and other crises – have all burgeoned while governments have asked the problem generators ‘what to do’.

“The English Government can rightly boast a number of positive moves for animal welfare, but consultation bias is one area that needs to be fixed, and fixed quickly. If objectivity matters, then the independent scientists should take the lead. If size matters, then the animal welfare sector has it. In any event, it makes no sense to prioritise advice from the problem-causers,” he added.

Elaine Toland, Director of the Animal Protection Agency, said, “Seeking evidence and recommendations on wild animal welfare primarily from exotic pet traders and keepers is akin to putting the fox in charge of the chicken coop, and yet this is how DEFRA routinely organises its consultations. Meanwhile those with the latest scientific evidence on the growing animal welfare and other crises are often side-lined. An urgent overhaul is needed to properly protect animals, as well as people and the environment.”

Thank you for reading, and don’t forget to check The Euro Weekly News for all your up-to-date local and international news stories.




FacebookTwitterRedditWhatsAppTelegramLinkedInEmailCopy Link
Go Back
Written by

Deirdre Tynan

Deirdre Tynan is an award-winning journalist who enjoys bringing the best in news reporting to Spain’s largest English-language newspaper, Euro Weekly News. She has previously worked at The Mirror, Ireland on Sunday and for news agencies, media outlets and international organisations in America, Europe and Asia. A huge fan of British politics and newspapers, Deirdre is equally fascinated by the political scene in Madrid and Sevilla. She moved to Spain in 2018 and is based in Jaen.


    • Chris Newman

      16 June 2021 • 09:15

      The UK government has a policy of stakeholder involvement, i.e., those who have direct, practical experience in working on an issue should be consulted. Campaigners who have no direct involvement (other than to campaign against an issue) are given less involvement as they have less to contribute to the debate.

      Both Elaine Tolland and Clifford Warwick are long standing Animal Rights campaigns who simply oppose keeping of exotics pets: The statement from Ms Tolland confirming this is below:

      BBC Inside Out statement Elaine Tolland Monday the 12th of November 2012

      Richard Daniel, presenter BBC Inside Out

      So to be clear what you want to do is see people banned from keeping these creatures as pets ultimately…

      Elaine Tolland, Animal Protection Agency

      We want to see a ban exactly on trade and keeping of reptiles as pets and we have huge public and political support to achieve our aims and I am confident we will get there…


    Leave a comment

    Your email address will not be published.